Editing Held (6R109)

From LOTR-TCG Wiki
Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 10: Line 10:
Held is essentially an extension of The One Ring, converting wounds on Frodo into burdens. This makes it an extremely niche card even before you consider its drawback at site 9 -- everybody starts the game with a similar effect on the table. Whether Held has any value at all depends on which version of The One Ring is being used and what dangers the player using Held is hoping to address.
Held is essentially an extension of The One Ring, converting wounds on Frodo into burdens. This makes it an extremely niche card even before you consider its drawback at site 9 -- everybody starts the game with a similar effect on the table. Whether Held has any value at all depends on which version of The One Ring is being used and what dangers the player using Held is hoping to address.


In Towers when the card was released, only {{Card|The One Ring, Isildur's Bane}} could convert archery wounds into burdens (and at great cost). {{Card|The One Ring, Answer to All Riddles}} not only offers the greatest strength (while worn, at least) of all rings in the format but also the greatest vitality, yet it doesn't offer much of a way to utilize burdens against a wounding deck -- the best the Free Peoples player can do is allow Frodo to lose a skirmish instead of another companion, which is moot if another unassigned companion would have won the skirmish anyway. A fellowship comprised of Frodo with 6 vitality and 4 companions with 3 vitality can only take 13 wounds before companions start dropping, while most wounding strategies deliver 15 or more wounds across sites 7-9 to leave Frodo dead or stuck skirmishing more minions that he can handle.
In Towers when the card was released, only {{Card|The One Ring, Isildur's Bane}} could convert archery wounds into burdens (and at great cost). {{Card|The One Ring, Such a Weight to Carry}} not only offers the greatest strength (while worn, at least) of all rings in the format but also the greatest vitality, yet it doesn't offer much of a way to utilize burdens against a wounding deck -- the best the Free Peoples player can do is allow Frodo to lose a skirmish instead of another companion, which is moot if another unassigned companion would have won the skirmish anyway. A fellowship comprised of Frodo with 6 vitality and 4 companions with 3 vitality can only take 13 wounds before companions start dropping, while most wounding strategies deliver 15 or more wounds across sites 7-9 to leave Frodo dead or stuck skirmishing more minions that he can handle.


This scenario is where Held can offer something: by putting as many wounds as possible from sites 7 and 8 on Frodo before discarding Held, the Free Peoples player may be able to get by with just two or three losses (especially if Frodo wasn't able to fully heal at site 6). Minions in wounding decks are typically lower strength, which means discarding Held with its text at site 8 is much easier to achieve and Frodo can expect to handle a minion on his own. If a companion has a defender bonus then Frodo may not have to fight at all despite the wounding thrown at the Free Peoples. In conjunction with Sam, the Free Peoples player can reliably assign up to 14 wounds to Frodo (5 wounds, plus 9 more converted to burdens) before allowing him to be overwhelmed and transfer the Ring to Sam, discarding Held in the process.
This scenario is where Held can offer something: by putting as many wounds as possible from sites 7 and 8 on Frodo before discarding Held, the Free Peoples player may be able to get by with just two or three losses (especially if Frodo wasn't able to fully heal at site 6). Minions in wounding decks are typically lower strength, which means discarding Held with its text at site 8 is much easier to achieve and Frodo can expect to handle a minion on his own. If a companion has a defender bonus then Frodo may not have to fight at all despite the wounding thrown at the Free Peoples. In conjunction with Sam, the Free Peoples player can reliably assign up to 14 wounds to Frodo (5 wounds, plus 9 more converted to burdens) before allowing him to be overwhelmed and transfer the Ring to Sam, discarding Held in the process.
Please note that all contributions to the LOTR-TCG Wiki may be edited, altered, or removed by other contributors. Your writing is liable to be edited mercilessly, so be sure to back up any major claims with links if possible.

To edit this page, please answer the question that appears below (more info):

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)